Should adjacent asymptomatic lumbar disc herniation be simultaneously rectified? A retrospective cohort study of 371 cases that received an open fusion or endoscopic discectomy only on symptomatic segments


Background context:

In the treatment of multiple disc herniations, the decision of whether to include the presumed asymptomatic lumbar disc herniation (asLDH) at adjacent segments remains uncertain. On the one hand, the untouched asLDH might soon become symptomatic and require treatment. On the other hand, additional surgery involving more segments will introduce greater risk, complications, and cost.


Purpose:

To investigate the prognosis of untreated asLDH after open fusion or percutaneous endoscopic lumbar discectomy (PELD) on symptomatic lumbar disc herniation (LDHs) in patients.


Study design:

This is a retrospective cohort study.


Patient sample:

A total of 371 patients with multiple disc herniations who underwent open discectomy and fusion or PELD only for symptomatic levels from January 2012 to July 2018 were included.


Outcome measures:

The primary outcome of interest was the development of symptomatic LDH at the previous asLDH of both groups that required reoperation. A second analysis was performed to compare the reoperation rate due to deterioration of asLDH among different severity grades of herniation. Reoperation rates of the original surgery at the symptomatic segment in both fusion and PELD groups were also reviewed.


Methods:

The patients were divided into two groups based on the surgical procedure, with 264 patients undergoing fusion surgery and 107 patients undergoing PELD. Clinical and imaging follow-ups were performed at routine intervals for more than 3 years. The reoperation rates due to deterioration of previously asLDH and failure of original surgery were investigated and compared between the two groups, as well as among the different severity grades of herniation.


Results:

The follow-up times were 48.2±24.2 and 41.1±17.5 months for the fusion and the PELD groups, respectively. The overall reoperation rate at the previous adjacent asLDH was 6.7% (25/317). According to the severity of the asLDH, a higher grade of asymptomatic herniation yielded a significantly higher rate of reoperation rate in both groups. If the nerve root was displaced by disk material prominently (nG2), the reoperation rate of asLDHs was 42.9% (3/7) in the fusion group and 20% (3/15) in the PELD group. Twenty out of 264 patients (7.6%) in the fusion group and 5 out of 107 patients (4.7%) in the PELD group required reoperation due to deterioration of asLDH. Reoperation rates due to failure of the original surgery were 7.6% (20/264) in the fusion group and 8.4% (9/107) in the PELD group.


Conclusions:

With multilevel LDHs, if the asLDH is left untreated, the reoperation rate is closely related to the degree of herniation. When confronting an asLDH graded as G2, a high possibility of reoperation should be clearly discussed with the patient, regardless of open fusion or PELD techniques. Considering that fusion and minimally invasive non-fusion techniques did not yield significantly different overall reoperation rates, ongoing degeneration seemed to have a greater contribution in terms of the deterioration of asLDH.


Keywords:

Multiple segmental lumbar disc herniation; adjacent segment disease; asymptomatic herniated disc herniation; percutaneous endoscopic lumbar discectomy; reoperation of lumbar surgery; spinal fusion.

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on vk
VK
Share on pinterest
Pinterest
Close Menu